You are not currently logged in. Are you accessing the unsecure (http) portal? Click here to switch to the secure portal.
Wiktenauer logo.png

Difference between revisions of "Tratt‍ato della sch‍erma (MS M.383)/Reconstruction"

From Wiktenauer
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
The MS M.383 was almost certainly longer when it was first written; its text makes various references to sections on ax, dagger, and grappling which are not present in the book's current state (though they may never have been completed), as well as a certain play of the sword in one hand which is likewise missing from that section (see 18v-c). Furthermore, the manuscript is composed of individual cut leaves rather than quires of bifolia, which means that there is no indicator of the original order of the surviving pages. The following speculative reconstruction is based on the manuscript contents and the organization of the other surviving copies; given that no fragment of the final three sections remains on which to base a reconstruction, none will be attempted.
+
The MS M.383 was almost certainly longer when it was first written; its text makes various references to sections on ax, dagger, and grappling which are not present in the book's current state (though they may never have been completed). Furthermore, there are several points where exactly eight figures are absent compared to the Getty and Pisani Dossi manuscripts.
 +
 
 +
The Morgan manuscript is composed of individual cut leaves rather than quires of bifolia, which means that there is no indicator of the original order of the surviving pages. The following speculative reconstruction is based on the manuscript contents and the organization of the other surviving copies; given that no fragment of the dagger section remains on which to base a reconstruction, none will be attempted. Attempting to simulate the collation is also pointless, since determining the quire size is impossible.
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 241 / 1
+
{{!}}+ 1 (241)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 11: Line 13:
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 245 / 2
+
{{!}}+ 2 (245)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 20: Line 22:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 246 / 3
+
{{!}}+ 3 (246)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 29: Line 31:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 247 / 4
+
{{!}}+ 4 (247)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 38: Line 40:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 248 / 5
+
{{!}}+ 5 (248)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 47: Line 49:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 249 / 6
+
{{!}}+ 6 (249)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 54: Line 56:
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
−
 
+
{{-}}
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 250 / 7
+
{{!}}+ 7 (250)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 65: Line 67:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 251 / 8
+
{{!}}+ 8 (251)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 74: Line 76:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 252 / 9
+
{{!}}+ 9 (252)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 83: Line 85:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 253 / 10
+
{{!}}+ 10 (253)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 92: Line 94:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 254 / 11
+
{{!}}+ 11 (254)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 101: Line 103:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 255 / 12
+
{{!}}+ 12 (255)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 108: Line 110:
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
−
 
+
{{-}}
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 256 / 13
+
{{!}}+ 13 (256)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 119: Line 121:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 242 / 14
+
{{!}}+ 14 (242)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 137: Line 139:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 244 / 16
+
{{!}}+ 16 (244)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 146: Line 148:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 243 / 15
+
{{!}}+ 15 (243)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 155: Line 157:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 258 / 18
+
{{!}}+ Missing
 +
{{!}}
 +
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 +
{{!}} [[file:Pisani-Dossi MS 27a.jpg|x150px|center]]
 +
{{!}} [[file:Pisani-Dossi MS 27b modified.png|x150px|center]]
 +
{{!}}}
 +
{{!}}}
 +
{{-}}
 +
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 +
{{!}}+ 18 (258)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 164: Line 175:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 257 / 17
+
{{!}}+ 17 (257)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 182: Line 193:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 259 / 19
+
{{!}}+ 19 (259)
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
Line 191: Line 202:
  
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
{{!}}+ 260 / 20
+
{{!}}+ Missing
 
{{!}}
 
{{!}}
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 
{{{!}} class="dpor"
−
{{!}} [[file:MS M.383 20r.png|x150px|center]]
+
{{!}} [[file:MS Ludwig XV 13 06r.jpg|x150px|center]]
−
{{!}} [[file:MS M.383 20v.png|x150px|center]]
+
{{!}} [[file:MS Ludwig XV 13 06v.jpg|x150px|center]]
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
 
{{!}}}
  
 +
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
 +
{{!}}+ Missing
 +
{{!}}
 +
{{{!}} class="dpor"
 +
{{!}} [[file:MS Ludwig XV 13 07r.jpg|x150px|center]]
 +
{{!}} [[file:MS Ludwig XV 13 07v.jpg|x150px|center]]
 +
{{!}}}
 +
{{!}}}
 
{{-}}
 
{{-}}
−
 
+
{{{!}} class="dporindex" style="height: 158px; width: 232px;"
−
<div style="width:1400px; clear:both;"><table style="border-collapse:collapse;">
+
{{!}}+ Missing
−
 
+
{{!}}
−
<tr>
+
{{{!}} class="dpor"
−
<td span style="font-size: 300%; font-family: serif;">I</td>
+
{{!}} [[file:MS Ludwig XV 13 08r.jpg|x150px|center]]
−
<td></td>
+
{{!}} [[file:MS M.383 20v.png|x150px|center]]
−
<td></td>
+
{{!}}}
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 1r.png|MS M.383 1v.png|01r|01v}}</td>
+
{{!}}}
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 2r.png|MS M.383 2v.png|02r|02v}}</td>
 
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 3r.png|MS M.383 3v.png|03r|03v}}</td>
 
−
<td style="border-right: 4px solid #979fb0;"> {{dpage|MS M.383 4r.png|MS M.383 4v.png|04r|04v}}</td>
 
−
<td style="border-left: 4px solid #979fb0;"> {{dpage|MS M.383 5r.png|MS M.383 5v.png|05r|05v}}</td>
 
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 6r.png|MS M.383 6v.png|06r|06v}}</td>
 
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 7r.png|MS M.383 7v.png|07r|07v}}</td>
 
−
<td>{{dpage|MS M.383 8r.png|MS M.383 8v.png|08r|08v}}</td>
 
−
<td></td>
 
−
<td></td>
 
−
<td span style="font-size: 300%; font-family: serif; padding-left: 0.5em;">I</td>
 
−
</tr>
 
−
 
 
−
</table>
 
−
</div>
 

Latest revision as of 03:00, 12 May 2021

The MS M.383 was almost certainly longer when it was first written; its text makes various references to sections on ax, dagger, and grappling which are not present in the book's current state (though they may never have been completed). Furthermore, there are several points where exactly eight figures are absent compared to the Getty and Pisani Dossi manuscripts.

The Morgan manuscript is composed of individual cut leaves rather than quires of bifolia, which means that there is no indicator of the original order of the surviving pages. The following speculative reconstruction is based on the manuscript contents and the organization of the other surviving copies; given that no fragment of the dagger section remains on which to base a reconstruction, none will be attempted. Attempting to simulate the collation is also pointless, since determining the quire size is impossible.

1 (241)
MS M.383 1r.png
MS M.383 1v.png
2 (245)
MS M.383 2r.png
MS M.383 2v.png
3 (246)
MS M.383 3r.png
MS M.383 3v.png
4 (247)
MS M.383 4r.png
MS M.383 4v.png
5 (248)
MS M.383 5r.png
MS M.383 5v.png
6 (249)
MS M.383 6r.png
MS M.383 6v.png


7 (250)
MS M.383 7r.png
MS M.383 7v.png
8 (251)
MS M.383 8r.png
MS M.383 8v.png
9 (252)
MS M.383 9r.png
MS M.383 9v.png
10 (253)
MS M.383 10r.png
MS M.383 10v.png
11 (254)
MS M.383 11r.png
MS M.383 11v.png
12 (255)
MS M.383 12r.png
MS M.383 12v.png


13 (256)
MS M.383 13r.png
MS M.383 13v.png
14 (242)
MS M.383 14r.png
MS M.383 14v.png
Missing
Pisani-Dossi MS 21a.jpg
Pisani-Dossi MS 21b.jpg
16 (244)
MS M.383 16r.png
MS M.383 16v.png
15 (243)
MS M.383 15r.png
MS M.383 15v.png
Missing
Pisani-Dossi MS 27a.jpg
Pisani-Dossi MS 27b modified.png


18 (258)
MS M.383 18r.png
MS M.383 18v.png
17 (257)
MS M.383 17r.png
MS M.383 17v.png
Missing
Pisani-Dossi MS 14a.jpg
Pisani-Dossi MS 14b.jpg
19 (259)
MS M.383 19r.png
MS M.383 19v.png
Missing
MS Ludwig XV 13 06r.jpg
MS Ludwig XV 13 06v.jpg
Missing
MS Ludwig XV 13 07r.jpg
MS Ludwig XV 13 07v.jpg


Missing
MS Ludwig XV 13 08r.jpg
MS M.383 20v.png
Retrieved from "https://wiktenauer.com/index.php?title=Tratt‍ato_della_sch‍erma_(MS_M.383)/Reconstruction&oldid=126122"